Our Verdict
FTMO scores higher overall (9.2/10 vs 8.9/10) on our methodology, which weighs profit split & payouts (35%), challenge fairness (30%), funding & scaling (20%), platform & support (15%). That makes it the stronger all-round choice for most people.
But a higher score doesn't make it the right pick for you. FTMO is built for serious forex and indices traders who want the most established firm, while Topstep targets cme futures traders who want a us-friendly, long-established program. If your situation matches the second description, the lower-scoring option is the better decision — the score measures general quality, not personal fit.